Cornell Governance at a Crossroads over “Rape Culture”
This is a two-part series. The first part looks at the current governance deadlock, and Part II looks at the Cornell Presidency in history.
On Friday, Nov. 9, the Faculty Senate, with 75 yes, 50 no, and 5 abstentions, adopted a “no confidence” resolution regarding Day Hall’s handling of the 2024 alleged sexual assault of a 20-year-old undergraduate woman. The adopted resolution reads, “Resolved: That the Faculty Senate has no confidence in the ability of the central administration to effectively address the ongoing crisis of sexual assault at Cornell University.” The Faculty Senate is a group of 138 faculty representatives who are elected by their departments to set academic policy on matters that affect more than one college or unit. It is one of five “shared governance bodies” on campus.
At the October 14 Faculty Senate meeting. President Kotlikoff spent about one hour responding to Senators’ questions and comments, and the debate continued on October 28, with an electronic vote following.
During the Oct. 14 debate, Kotlikoff said, “If this university feels that they will solve this problem by replacing a president, that itself is not good for Cornell’s reputation. I don’t think it’s the right way to address situations like this.”
RELATED: Faculty Senate Votes No Confidence in Day Hall
Although a majority of the Faculty Senators ultimately voted “no confidence,” respected faculty leaders came out publicly opposing the motion. Dean of the Faculty, Chris B. Schaffer, submitted a public written comment on the Faculty Senate page opposing the motion:
“I hope the Senate can help engender a sustained faculty commitment to confronting sexual violence. That means acting on what we already know: helping students reach support, strengthening our ability to respond when they disclose an assault, and participating in prevention efforts. It means listening to students, drawing on existing research, and evaluating whether our efforts work. And it means investing in scholarship that can deepen our understanding and guide lasting change.
“I oppose this resolution because it leaves the basis and purpose of our collective judgment unclear.”
Three senior Chemistry professors, including one who just finished a term as a faculty-elected Trustee, also opposed the motion, based on President Kotlikoff’s past performance:
“Collectively, this long line of dire circumstances required crisis management, vision, careful thought and action, while balancing many conflicting interests. Therefore, we submit that these examples of past performances should bolster our confidence that President Kotlikoff, Provost Bala and other members of their team will be agents of change, rising to meet the current challenge in addressing sexual misconduct at Cornell and helping all of us make this University a better place.”
In a separate comment, Geoff Coates, another senior Chemistry professor, wrote:
“A vote of no confidence now is akin to passengers on a plane encountering turbulence and deciding, mid-flight, to remove a capable pilot from the cockpit – only to find that none of them know how to land it.”
Further, Kathryn Boor ‘80, who served as Dean of CALS and then as Dean of the Graduate School, wrote opposing the motion.
Other faculty also submitted written comments with their ballots, which were posted on the resolution’s webpage.
Within an hour of the vote being announced, Board Chair Anne Smalling ‘87 issued a statement affirming confidence in President Kotlikoff and effectively rejecting the adopted Faculty Senate motion:
“The Board of Trustees remains confident that President Kotlikoff and his administration are the right leaders to thoughtfully and comprehensively address the serious problem of sexual assault on our campus. This confidence is rooted not only in the administration’s actions to date and plans moving forward but also in its track record of navigating complex problems, as it did in restoring federal funding, preserving free speech, and leading the University through Covid.”
In other words, when the time comes for the Trustees to take up the sexual assault issue, it will be in terms of the findings of the independent Sally Yates investigation rather than the Faculty Senate motion of “no confidence.” This puts the faculty as a whole in a frustrating stalemate.
Next Steps
There are no clear next steps for the group that sponsored the resolution. Although thousands protested on October 6 against sexual assault, it is doubtful that similarly sized demonstrations would gather for accountability against specific individuals. Also, the searing media spotlight on Cornell has lifted in the wake of the midterm elections.
It was unrealistic to expect the Trustees to act in response to a motion of “no confidence” that did not name any individuals, particularly in light of opposition by senior faculty. As former Cornell President Dale R. Corson (who first synthesized element #85 Astatine and then worked as a physicist on the Manhattan Project) observed, “The Board of Trustees works by potential energy, not kinetic energy.” In other words, the potential threat of Trustee intervention is more powerful than any subsequent action by the Board.
Here, the Trustees, recognizing that employees might shape the truth to protect their careers, are relying upon an experienced outside evaluator. If anyone “walks the plank,” it will be based upon the evidence gathered in Yates’ report, and will probably happen outside public scrutiny.
When universities have a jurisdictional battle between Trustee and faculty prerogatives, there is no suitable resolution mechanism short of a general strike or mass protests. In 1975, a similar situation developed at the University of Texas, Austin. A formal Presidential search had been conducted which included participation by campus representatives, and the search forwarded a list of finalists to the UT Board of Regents. The Regents selected Lorene L. Rogers to be the next President, although the campus search committee had voted to exclude her from the list. Students and faculty held protest rallies, but the most effective tactic was a complete boycott of faculty meetings where she was scheduled to speak or preside. Rogers lasted four years as UT President.
The Trustee rejection of the Faculty Senate motion is not a complete surprise. Some people note that the Faculty Senate was influenced by a two-page letter sent by Jane Doe’s attorney claiming that she felt “unsupported” during her 2024 process. This added an emotional element to the debate and appeared to be a transparent effort to push Day Hall to reach a financial settlement with Jane Doe.
The Trustee gave Kotlikoff the President title in recognition of his handling of the challenges posed by the Trump Administration. Since Trump still has two years left in his term, only a dire reason would lead the Trustees to make a switch before January 2029.
Also, Cornell has a history of its Presidents serving for long tenures and not leaving at the first crisis. The longest-serving President is Jacob Gould Schurman at 28 years:
| No. | President | Term Start | Term End | Years Served |
| 1 | Andrew Dickson White | 1866 | 1885 | 19 |
| 2 | Charles Kendall Adams | 1885 | 1892 | 7 |
| 3 | Jacob Gould Schurman | 1892 | 1920 | 28 |
| 4 | Livingston Farrand | 1921 | 1937 | 16 |
| 5 | Edmund Ezra Day | 1937 | 1949 | 12 |
| 6 | Deane Waldo Malott | 1951 | 1963 | 12 |
| 7 | James Alfred Perkins | 1963 | 1969 | 6 |
| 8 | Dale R. Corson | 1969 | 1977 | 8 |
| 9 | Frank H. T. Rhodes | 1977 | 1995 | 18 |
| 10 | Hunter R. Rawlings III | 1995 | 2003 | 8 |
| 11 | Jeffrey S. Lehman ‘77 | 2003 | 2005 | 2 |
| 12 | David J. Skorton | 2006 | 2015 | 9 |
| 13 | H. Elizabeth Garrett | 2015 | 2016 | ~1 |
| 14 | Martha E. Pollack | 2017 | 2024 | 7 |
Cornell’s history of Presidential transitions will be discussed in Part II.
