Cornell University near Sage Hall | photo by Eben Hill

The Cornell Presidency Through History

This is a two-part series on Cornell’s current governance deadlock. In Part 1, we looked at the current situation. This part looks back for historic precedents and patterns.

Judging by the chants and picket signs at recent demonstrations, many protesters focused their anger over sexual assault at Cornell into a demand that President Kotlikoff must resign. However, the “no confidence” text adopted by the Faculty Senate spoke in terms of the “central administration” rather than any individuals.

As is typically used, “central administration” includes many mid- and low-level administrators as well as Cornell’s highest officials. While Cornell’s Presidency rarely changes hands, the lower-level staff turns over much more frequently and in most cases without the involvement of the Trustees, President, or shared governance bodies.

Perhaps some people expected that as soon as the resolution passed, President Kotlikoff would quickly resign. In fact, Cornell Presidential transitions do not work that way.

Both Cornell’s experience when under a national media spotlight and when an incumbent President loses broad support can teach us in this current moment.

Public Pressure

There have been situations causing Cornell’s Presidents serious embarrassment, but they did not result in a change of leadership, with one exception.

In Sept. 1880, Jennie McGraw Fiske died and left her $2.2 million (over $75 million in 2026 dollars) estate to Cornell to build a library. Her husband, the University Librarian, contested the will and took the case up to the United States Supreme Court. The Court ruled that the bulk of the estate should go to Fiske, greatly angering Henry W. Sage, Chair of the Board. The case did not affect the stature of Presidents White or Adams.

In 1903, neighboring landowners opposed the tree-clearing policies of the New York State College of Forestry, and Governor Benjamin B. Odell, Jr. vetoed further funding in the NYS budget. The College was immediately terminated. President Jacob Gould Schurman did not make the controversy a matter of personal status.

In 1950, McCarthyism swept the nation with fears that Communists were secretly infiltrating the nation’s universities. Cornell faculty debated enforcing loyalty oaths (that were already required by NY State law). In 1953, one Los Alamos physicist who followed Hans Bethe back to Cornell — Phillip Morrison – was subpoenaed by the Senate Internal Security Subcommittee about his past student Communist Party membership. Trustees and alumni mounted pressure on Theodore Paul Wright, the Acting President of Cornell, to fire Morrison, but Bethe remained supportive, and Robert R. Wilson (who pioneered the Cornell Synchrotron and Fermilab) declared that Morrison had “demonstrated his patriotism by the distinguished role he played in the wartime development of the atomic bomb.” The incoming Cornell President Deane Malott allowed Morrison to keep his faculty post, but had him shift from nuclear physics to study other topics. Others, such as Visiting Professor Harry C. Steinmetz, were outright canceled. Both the Steinmetz and Morrison cases demonstrate how cancel culture, mob rule, and moral panic can spread within academia even in the face of stiff and principled opposition.

In 1958, Cornell student demonstrations made national headlines for protesting new restrictions on female Cornell students attending Collegetown parties. The protestors marched to the President’s house, where President Malott was entertaining Trustee Chair John L. Collyer ‘17. The protestors pelted them with eggs. At the next Trustee meeting, the Trustees spontaneously raised whether the mob leaders should receive their diplomas. These Trustees advocated direct action at a time when student conduct was delegated to the faculty. Cooler heads prevailed, and the students were allowed to graduate consistent with conduct proceedings.

On April 19, 1969, a group of black students occupied Willard Straight Hall and brought in rifles. The students were protesting letters of reprimand that the student conduct board had issued to a different group of black students for damaging property during an earlier protest. The Central Administration agreed to seek a lifting of those letters as well as to provide amnesty for the WSH occupiers. However, at the time, the University Faculty controlled the judicial system. The President took the amnesty request to a University Faculty meeting, which voted it down. By this point, 8,000 students had occupied Barton Hall, and they threatened further violence. The University Faculty then re-voted and granted the amnesty. In light of serious opposition from senior faculty to the manner in which President James Perkins handled the crisis, Perkins resigned, and Provost Dale R. Corson became President.

Given the past record of Presidential resignations, it is not surprising that the Cornell Trustees continue to back President Kotlikoff in the current instance. Although the media scrutiny of the past month was intense, Cornell and its Presidents have survived greater scrutiny in the past.

Difficult Transitions

At the start, Ezra Cornell and A.D. White had a strong partnership that predated the launch of Cornell University. This set the pattern of the Cornell President working closely with the Chair of the Board of Trustees. 

Seven years into his Presidency, Charles Adams angered the Trustees in disputes about awarding honorary degrees and whether the faculty or the President had final say in faculty hiring and promotions. These tensions led to Adam’s resignation in 1892.

In 2003, Cornell hired Jeffrey Lehman ‘77, who was serving as Dean of the University of Michigan Law School, as President. This was the only case where Cornell hired an alumnus as President. Reportedly, Lehman drew criticism for his overcommitment of Cornell resources to international programs, as well as his wife actively participating on the Third Floor of Day Hall as if being an unofficial “deputy president.” Lehman was requested to resign before he understood the magnitude of his opposition. The departure was a surprise to many. After two years of Cornell service, he landed at the Smithsonian Wilson Center for International Scholars as a Resident Scholar.

Jon A. Lindseth ’56, Trustee Emeritus and “Presidential Counselor”, published an open letter on Jan. 23, 2024, calling for Martha Pollack to resign as Cornell President. On Jan. 27, the Board promptly adopted a unanimous resolution of support for Pollack. Later, on May 9, Pollack announced her voluntary retirement, after seven years in the post. Provost Kotlikoff was announced as Acting President, effective July 1.

If a major personnel transaction were to happen at Cornell, it would be discussed in private rooms rather than debated on the floor of the Faculty Senate.

PART 1: Cornell Governance at a Crossroads over “Rape Culture”

Author

  • Review Staff

    Cornell students, community members, and alumni contribute to the Cornell Review. Staff consists of student writers collaborating on articles, with occasional guest submissions as well.

    View all posts

Related